Is slow economic growth good or bad?

In United States and many other advanced economies, the growth rate of GDP per person (or per hour) considerably fell in the past two decades. Should we worry about that? Will economic growth be faster after the COVID-19 pandemic? Most economists (including me) would say that economic growth would in general be a good thing as long as it does not lead to faster climate change: for instance, the arguments go that higher growth would help increase wages and reduce inequality and contribute to the financing of the energy transition towards renewable sources of energy.

Dietrich Vollrath of the University of Houston argues, however, that low growth is not necessarily bad, but it is a sign for success. As he convincingly explains in his recent book («Fully Grown: Why a Stagnant Economy is a Sign of Success», University of Chicago Press), growth is lower now because of past successes. In particular, women are now better educated and their labor market participation rate has increased. As a side effect, they choose to have fewer children. This has led to a demographic transition (less young people and more retired people) that dampens economic growth. In addition, when people get richer, they buy more services instead of ever more cars and washing machines. But productivity growth for some services that require personal interactions (for instance, education, health care, child care, some leisure activities) is usually low because the potential to automate or outsource is limited.

These arguments are in general well known. However, it is always important to keep in mind that these developments do not have to be a reason for pessimism, but are also a sign of past successes such as high productivity growth in manufacturing, an improvement in the rights of women and a higher labor force participation of women. One does not have to agree with each argument made in the book to acknowledge that Vollrath convincingly succeeds in pointing out past successes. Low economic growth does not necessarily have to be bad, but can be the result of past favorable developments that increased our well-being.

The book is well-written and highly recommended:

Vollrath, D. (2020): “Fully Grown: Why a Stagnant Economy Is a Sign of Success”, University of Chicago Press; First Edition (15. January 2020).

Success! You're on the list.

Some of my blog posts and economic forecasts are first reserved to my paying subscribers. After two weeks, all articles are publicly available. If you would like to get instantaneous access, you can subscribe for 5 US dollars per month (or the equivalent amount in your currency). You can unsubscribe at any time:


%d bloggers like this: